Allegations: The complaint contains grave allegations of continuing attacks by
the military authorities against trade unionists, workers and civil servants who are calling
for the return to civilian rule following the coup d’état in Myanmar on 1 February 2021. The
allegations include intimidation and threats against trade unionists, workers and civil
servants to ensure their return to work and to renounce their participation in the Civil
Disobedience Movement, suspension from posts and use of striker replacements, withdrawal of
benefits and professional competency certificates, police lists of workers and trade
unionists for arrest, imprisonment and detention and numerous deaths following interventions
by the military and police forces in peaceful protests, including the torture and killing of
union leaders. The allegations also concern anti-union attacks and attempts at dismantling
the independent trade union movement in the country
- 440. The Committee last examined this case (submitted in March 2021) at
its May–June 2024 meeting, when it presented an interim report to the Governing Body
[see 407th Report, paras 268–311, approved by the Governing Body at its 351st Session].
- 441. The International Trade Union Confederation (ITUC) provided
additional allegations in communications dated 24 February and 7 May 2025.
- 442. The State Administration Council (SAC) Ministry of Labour and the
Permanent Mission in Geneva provided a reply in communications dated 6 March, 15 April
and 28 May 2025.
- 443. Myanmar has ratified Convention No. 87 but has not ratified the
Right to Organise and Collective Bargaining Convention, 1949 (No. 98).
A. Previous examination of the case
A. Previous examination of the case- 444. At its May–June 2024 meeting, the Committee made the following
recommendations [see 407th Report, para. 311]:
- (a) The Committee urges the military
authorities to desist from any and all acts of retaliation against any individual or
organization which provided information to the Commission of Inquiry or continues to
engage in the ILO procedures ensuring follow-up to the Commission’s
recommendations.
- (b) The Committee recalls its previous recommendation that
steps be taken without delay to ensure the immediate release of trade unionists and
workers arrested or detained for action in relation to the restoration of their
trade union rights and democracy in the country, as well as the call on the military
authorities to ensure the release of Thet Hnin Aung, and requests to be informed of
all steps taken to this end and a copy of the judgment against Thet Hnin
Aung.
- (c) The Committee once again urges the responsible military authorities to
cease immediately the ongoing use of violence against workers and trade unionists
participating in peaceful protesters and to have independent investigations carried
out into the allegations of violence against them workers and trade unionists with a
view to determining responsibilities and punishing the perpetrators. The Committee
requests detailed information on the steps taken in this regard and the outcome of
the investigations. The Committee, further noting the issue of revocation of
citizenship of trade unionists raised in the conclusions of the Committee on the
Application of Standards and the Commission of Inquiry recommendations, calls on the
military authorities to reinstate citizenship to the trade unionists and workers
concerned and to indicate the steps taken in this regard.
- (d) The Committee once
again firmly urges the repeal and amendment of section 505-A of the Penal Code,
section 124 of the Criminal Code, section 38(c) of the Electronic Transaction Act
(ETA), the withdrawal of the surveillance powers that were restored to the wards and
villages under the amended Ward or Village-tract Administration Law and the
withdrawal of the declaration of the trade unions declared as unlawful so as to
ensure full respect for the basic civil liberties necessary for the exercise of
freedom of association so that workers’ and employers’ organizations can carry out
their activities and functions without threat of intimidation or harm and in a
climate of complete security.
- (e) The Committee calls on the responsible
authorities to continue to take steps to ensure the reinstatement of all remaining
civil servants, healthcare workers and teachers dismissed or suspended for their
participation in the CDM and to restore any benefits that may have been
withdrawn.
- (f) Recalling the importance of ensuring a climate for the full
exercise of freedom of association for all workers in the public and private
sectors, the Committee once again calls on Myanmar to take the appropriate steps in
this regard and to keep it informed of the specific measures taken.
- (g) The
Committee urges the military authorities to fully recognize the critical importance
of ensuring these rights and freedoms to the workers and employers of the country as
a necessary prerequisite for the restoration of democracy and the exercise of trade
union activities and to take all necessary steps to create a climate where freedom
of association can be fully and meaningfully restored in Myanmar.
- (h) Noting
with deep regret the failure of the military authorities to implement the
recommendations of the Commission of Inquiry and of this Committee and the
continuing situation of extreme violence and repression in the country, the
Committee draws the Governing Body’s attention to the extreme seriousness and
urgency of this case so that it may consider any further measures to secure
compliance therewith.
B. The complainant’s new allegations
B. The complainant’s new allegations- 445. In its communications dated 24 February and 7 May 2025, the ITUC
submits supplemental information on the situation of freedom of association in the
country, alleging a deteriorating environment for the exercise of labour rights and
continued escalation of violence. The ITUC alleges that the military has taken no steps
to implement the recommendations of the Commission of Inquiry, the resolution of the
International Labour Conference or the decisions of the Governing Body and has instead
resorted to the use of more lethal weapons and indiscriminate killing of civilians,
including workers and unionists. It claims that the environment has become extremely
dangerous for trade unionists and labour rights activists who are labelled as supporters
of terrorism, the People’s Defence Force (PDF) or foreign agents. In the complainant’s
view, this amounts to retaliation for their calling for a restoration of democracy and
an attack on their freedom of expression. The complainant also reports increased
restrictions on the freedom of movement of individuals within the conscription age
range, increasing practices of forced labour and human trafficking, the continued use of
martial law, the prosecution and imprisonment of several journalists, the raiding of the
offices of a welfare association, an increase in the use of torture against detained
human rights defenders and trade unionists, sexual violence against prisoners in
interrogation centres, prisons and other detention sites, as well as continued
criminalization of civil liberties. In this regard, the complainant denounces the arrest
of Naing Lin Aung, a youth activist who was organizing demonstrations calling for the
adoption of measures under article 33 of the ILO Constitution for the implementation of
the Commission of Inquiry recommendations; he remains incommunicado since his arrest at
the end of March 2025.
- 446. The complainant further reports extreme cruelty and grave negligence
by the SAC in responding to the earthquake that hit Myanmar at the end of March 2025,
alleging continuous, deliberate and indiscriminate aerial bombings of civilian areas,
despite a military-declared ceasefire, as well as systematic obstruction of rescues,
including through the imposition of additional restrictions on freedom of expression,
imposition of curfews, heightened security checks and confiscation of aid material.
There were instances where trade unionists attempting to join the rescue efforts were
stopped by the military and asked whether they were supporters of the armed resistance
groups or the Civil Disobedience Movement (CDM). According to the complainant, this
situation has caused imminent threat to the lives and activities of the remaining
independent unionists, human rights defenders and humanitarian actors residing in the
attacked regions and has accelerated the risks and challenges for trade unions to
provide services and support their members, including with regard to serious labour
rights violations at the workplace.
- 447. In particular, the complainant alleges that the executive committee
members of the Confederation of Trade Unions Myanmar (CTUM) remain under arrest warrants
with their passports or citizenship voided. Out of the 151 CTUM members who had been
arrested for carrying out union activities or taking part in public protests, 65 remain
in detention and 2 died, including Kaung Khant Kyaw, member of the Hinthada Teachers’
Union, who was executed. Kyaw Naing Oo and Paing Thae Oo from the Taungoo Teachers’
Union in Bago region were sentenced to life imprisonment for having allegedly joined the
PDFs. A further 8 unionists detained at the Oh Bo prison in Mandalay are reported to
have been killed during the March 2025 earthquake. The complainant further alleges that
Thet Hnin Aung, General Secretary of the Myanmar Industry, Crafts and Services Trade
Union Federation (MICS-TUsF), who had been sentenced to seven years’ imprisonment with
hard labour on fabricated charges of terrorism, after having previously served two years
in prison, has been tortured in detention and locked up incommunicado. After he
disclosed the prison conditions to the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC)
in December 2024, he was further beaten and confined to an extremely small cell. It is
alleged that following visits by the EU delegation and the ILO Liaison Officer, he has
not been allowed further visits from the outside world. Khine Thinzar Aye, the CTUM
communications chief, also spoke about the torture and sexual abuse to which she was
subjected during military interrogation, after she was released from prison in June
2024, and she has now fled to ethnic-controlled areas to escape military surveillance
and to resume, as much as possible, her trade union work (a document containing details
on the arrested and detained unionists was submitted to the Committee but was requested
to be kept confidential to protect the concerned individuals from retaliation).
- 448. The complainant further alleges a systematic smearing campaign
against the CTUM and its leadership, including against those seeking refuge outside the
country, as well as its affiliates, and considers that this amounts to an anti-union
attack ultimately aimed at taking over the CTUM by cloning it into a “yellow” union and
an agency of the State. It states that, in February 2025, the military authorities
supported the establishment by former leaders of the CTUM and of the Industrial Workers
Federation of Myanmar (IWFM) of a parallel trade union confederation with the same name
as the CTUM in Burmese, so as to hold trade union meetings and spread false information
about CTUM and IWFM leaders. At the beginning of February, the former Vice-President of
the CTUM who had resigned immediately after the military coup, convened a meeting
disguised as a fake CTUM congress and announced 5 new CTUM executive committee members
and 23 new central committee members from a pre-determined list of individuals who had
no knowledge about it (the invitation to the congress, the list of individuals and a
photograph of the meeting were provided by the complainant). Similarly, in January 2025,
the former president of the Mining Workers Federation of Myanmar (MWFM), affiliated to
the IWFM, purported to convene a labour law training workshop in Yangon and converted it
into a fake congress, in contravention of the union’s constitution and in the absence of
a decision to this effect from the IWFM leadership, with a staged election of 15
pro-military individuals to replace the incumbent IWFM central committee members.
According to the complainant, workers were forced to attend these meetings under
pressure from their employers following a request to this effect from the SAC Ministry
of Labour and were given “ballots” to “re-elect” trade union executives under military
coercion and surveillance. They were thus forced into organizations under the control of
the military or of businesses which are themselves under the influence of the military.
The complainant adds in this regard that in more than 360 complaints of labour rights
violations that occurred in garment factories between January and December 2024 and were
received by the IWFM, their members were unable to be represented by a trade union of
their choice (a detailed list of the incidents was provided, disaggregated by factory
and country of brand).
- 449. It is further alleged that martial law remains in place and
continues to restrict civil liberties and labour rights. In addition, since May 2024,
the Ministry of Transport and Communications has blocked the use of personal data
protection and social media applications by individuals, including virtual private
networks (VPNs), Signal, Facebook, X, Instagram and WhatsApp. A new law, the
Cybersecurity Law No. 1/2025, which came into force in January 2025, puts into effect
the ban on unapproved usage and more stringent licensing measures and also stipulates
penalties of up to six months’ imprisonment for the use of VPNs and up to two years for
acts of transmission of unwanted and unsolicited messages, emails or data via a network,
including reading, sorting and sharing articles from media outlets or groups banned or
labelled as terrorist. Digital service and platform providers are required to keep the
personal data of its customers and share them with the authorities upon request.
According to the complainant, the law undermines freedom of expression and seriously
affects the communications, service provisions and activities of trade unions within and
outside Myanmar, in particular since trade unionists that have rejected the military
coup and refused to cooperate with the military are labelled as part of the PDF. These
unions nevertheless continue to operate underground and to monitor labour rights
violations.
C. The reply from Myanmar
C. The reply from Myanmar- 450. In communications dated 6 March, 15 April and 28 May 2025, the
Permanent Mission transmits information from the SAC Ministry of Labour in response to
the additional allegations from the complainant and the Committee’s previous
recommendations. It is stated that the Ministry of Labour is committed to upholding and
adhering to freedom of association, acts as the registrar under the Labour Organization
Law, 2011 and has not prohibited or hindered activities of labour organizations. In line
with this law, the right to form a labour organization, the right to join as a member,
the right to hold independent funds, the right to freely draft its own organizational
rules, the right to freely elect executive members and matters relating to removal from
office and resignation can be carried out in accordance with the law and the
constitution of the relevant labour organization. Issues arising between members of a
labour organization can be resolved in accordance with the law. Between October 2024 and
March 2025, 64 new workers’ organizations were formed, showing that Myanmar practises
freedom of association and does not prohibit workers’ organizations. To ensure that
workers fully enjoy their labour rights, they can file complaints with the respective
labour offices and, in addition, the Ministry of Labour actively monitors labour-related
demands on social media and dispatches teams to conduct field investigations and provide
timely resolution. In the post-earthquake situation, the Ministry of Labour engaged in
verification of safety of factories and arranged for workers to be transferred where
necessary and for those affected by factory closure to receive financial benefits.
- 451. It is further indicated, concerning action taken against individuals
for allegedly exercising labour rights and engaging in activities for the restoration of
democracy, including peaceful demonstrations, that no union member has been arrested,
had cases filed against them or subjected to violence for exercising their labour rights
in accordance with the law. Actions have only been taken against individuals cooperating
with armed organizations, carrying out destructive activities and undermining national
stability, which is unrelated to their labour activities. Similarly, only organizations
which are not registered in accordance with the law are declared illegal. Civil servants
removed from their positions since February 2021 in accordance with civil service
regulations for unauthorized absence, including desertion from civil service due to
being threatened by terrorist groups or subjected to criticism on social media, can
report to the relevant ministry; 7,904 such civil servants have already been reappointed
to their positions. Furthermore, while Myanmar is currently under a state of emergency
and necessary amendments have been made to certain laws for security purposes, labour
related laws have not been amended.
- 452. With regard to the status of the CTUM, it is indicated that the
organization was lawfully registered in 2015 and its executive committee composed of 29
members was elected in February 2020; its term expired in February 2022. Among the total
of 3,116 organizations that received registration certificates since 2011, the only one
which was registered at the highest level as a Myanmar labour confederation was the
CTUM. However, it suspended its participation in tripartite mechanisms, issued
statements of support to the National Unity Government, which had been declared a
terrorist group, and some of its leaders, including the President, have not participated
in labour matters since February 2021. This shows that they have acted against ILO
principles and have deviated from their intended purpose by not carrying out
organizational affairs of the labour organization despite holding a registration
certificate. Furthermore, the President, Treasurer and Secretary live illegally abroad
and have not provided an account of organizational assets and funds, which were
requested by CTUM members in the country. These members reported that the organization
lacked leadership, its structure collapsed and its duties could therefore not be carried
out. The CTUM as such, has not been dissolved, but since the CTUM lacked effective
leadership and as some of its leaders were involved under section 124-A of the Penal
Code, and to facilitate continued resolution of the organization’s property and
financial matters raised by the workers, the remaining CTUM leaders within the country
convened a congress on 6 February 2025, during which a central committee and an
executive committee were elected. The formation and election of the new CTUM leadership
was conducted by workers through a free and fair election, in line with the Labour
Organization Law and the organization’s constitution. The CTUM, with its newly elected
executive members, is therefore not a parallel organization but rather the same
organization with the vacant executive committee members replaced. On 10 February 2025,
the executive committee reported that it was carrying out the duties of the
organization.
- 453. With regard to the situation of the MICS-TUsF General Secretary, in
response to the ILO’s request to meet with him, the Ministry of Labour obtained
permission from the relevant authorities and facilitated a meeting with the Liaison
Officer on 25 February 2025. He was also visited by the Ambassador of the European Union
in January 2025, has access to adequate medical care and also received 11 family visits
up to November 2024.
- 454. Concerning other individuals mentioned by the ITUC, the reply from
the military authorities confirms that unionists Kyaw Naing Oo and Paing Thae Oo are
serving a prison sentence based on charges under section 54 of the Counter-Terrorism Law
and that Khine Thinzar Aye, the CTUM communications chief, was sentenced to three years
of imprisonment for intending to cause fear, spreading false information and inciting to
commit crime; she was released in April 2024 upon completion of her sentence. According
to the military authorities, there is no record of unionist Kaung Khant Kyaw being
sentenced to death. Details are also provided on the sentences against several
journalists who were charged under the Counter-Terrorism Law for gathering military
information from terrorist groups and disseminating false news.
- 455. Detailed information is further provided on steps taken to eliminate
forced labour, including the applicable legislation and regulations prohibiting forced
labour, awareness-raising programmes and training seminars on forced labour and human
trafficking, setting-up of billboards and distribution of pamphlets, the functioning of
the National Complaints Mechanism, preventive measures to verify the age of military
recruits to avoid underage recruitment and prison visits by the ICRC.
- 456. It is also reported that while some so-called workers who are
self-exiled demand the imposition of measures under article 33 of the ILO Constitution,
real workers living in Myanmar are opposed to this and show it by way of demonstrations.
Nai Lin Aung, the youth activist mentioned by the ITUC, was charged under section 505-A
of the Penal Code for his unlawful activities and is on trial at the Insein Township
Court. The reply reiterates the invitation previously extended to the ILO to conduct a
high-level visit to the country to ensure that the ILO is aware of the situation on the
ground regarding Conventions Nos 87 and the Forced Labour Convention, 1930 (No.
29).
D. The Committee’s conclusions
D. The Committee’s conclusions- 457. The Committee recalls that the serious allegations in this case
concern continuing attacks by the military authorities against trade unionists, workers
and civil servants calling for the return to civilian rule following the coup d’état in
Myanmar on 1 February 2021. The grave allegations include killing, torture and other
acts of brutality, numerous arrests, imprisonment, detention, intimidation and threats
against workers and trade unionists who oppose the military regime, including for
participation in peaceful protests, and retaliation through dismissals, suspensions, use
of striker replacements and withdrawal of benefits. The allegations also refer to
serious restrictions on the basic civil liberties of trade unionists and continued
attempts by the military authorities to discredit and dismantle independent trade
unions.
- 458. The Committee further recalls from its previous examination of the
case that the Commission of Inquiry appointed by the Governing Body to examine the
non-observance by Myanmar of Conventions Nos 87 and 29 established, in its August 2023
report, that, in the light of the gravity of the issues raised, the situation and the
progress achieved on its recommendations should be the subject of active supervision by
the ILO supervisory bodies concerned. The Committee recalls in this regard that a large
part of the Commission’s recommendations are relevant to the matters addressed in the
case before it, namely, the call on the military authorities to: immediately cease all
forms of violence, including gender-based violence, torture and other inhumane treatment
against trade union leaders and members and other persons in relation to the exercise of
legitimate workers’ or employers’ activities; revoke all military orders or other
measures, decreed since February 2021 and identified as restricting freedom of
association and the basic civil liberties of trade unionists; revoke the withdrawal of
citizenship and return travel documents to the trade union leaders and members concerned
without delay; and end all forms of interference in the establishment, administration
and functioning of trade unions at all levels, including interference in the election of
trade union leadership, labour dispute resolution, conduct of collective action and
administrative dissolution or suspension of trade unions. The Committee notes in this
regard, the latest allegations submitted by the complainant which point to a failure by
the military authorities to implement the recommendations of the Commission of Inquiry
and observes that, at its 353rd Session (March 2025), the Governing Body noted with
utmost concern the continued absence of any concrete action towards the implementation
of the recommendations of the Commission of Inquiry and reiterated its previous decision
to place on the agenda of the 113th Session (June 2025) of the International Labour
Conference an item concerning measures under article 33 of the ILO Constitution to
secure compliance by Myanmar with the recommendations of the Commission of Inquiry. The
Committee also notes the views expressed by the SAC Ministry of Labour, according to
which only some “so-called workers who are in self-exile” militate for the imposition of
measures under article 33 while “real workers” within the country are opposed to it. The
Committee observes with concern the complainant’s allegations in this regard that a
youth activist demonstrating for measures to be taken under article 33 of the ILO
Constitution for the implementation of the Commission of Inquiry recommendations was
arrested and remains incommunicado, and notes the reply from the military authorities
confirming that he was charged under section 505-A of the Penal Code and is currently on
trial. While the imposition of measures under article 33 of the ILO Constitution to
secure compliance with the recommendations of the Commission of Inquiry falls within the
competence of the International Labour Conference, it touches directly on the matters
addressed in the case before it and the Committee will therefore follow the
institutional developments in this regard.
- 459. With regard to its own previous recommendations, in particular
concerning the steps to ensure the immediate release of trade unionists and workers
arrested or detained for action in relation to the restoration of their trade union
rights and democracy in the country, including the General Secretary of the MICS–TUsF
(recommendation (b)), the Committee notes the complainant’s additional allegations that
the arrest warrants against the CTUM leadership are still pending, that at least
65 trade unionists continue to be imprisoned, including 2 sentenced to life
imprisonment, that there are reports of serious allegations of torture, sexual violence
and other abuses in detention and that 8 unionists detained at the Oh Bo prison in
Mandalay were killed during the March 2025 earthquake. In particular, the Committee
notes with deep concern the allegations that Khine Thinzar Aye, the CTUM communications
chief, was subjected to torture and sexual violence when interrogated by the military
forces and that Thet Hnin Aung, the MICS–TUsF General Secretary, remains detained and
has been tortured and locked up incommunicado, including as retaliation for having
disclosed his prison conditions to the ICRC. The Committee regrets to observe that the
only information provided by the military authorities in this regard refers to the
release of Khine Thinzar Aye following the completion of her sentence in April 2024 and
to prison visits conducted by the Ambassador of the European Union and the ILO Liaison
Officer to the MICS-TUsF General Secretary in January and February 2025, respectively,
which were facilitated by the SAC Ministry of Labour. The military authorities fail to
provide a copy of the judgment sentencing the MICS-TUsF General Secretary, previously
requested by the Committee, which could shed further light on the precise nature of his
condemnation, as well as the circumstances of his trial. Neither do they address the
extremely serious allegation that he has been mistreated, including as retaliation for
exposing prison conditions or the allegation that 65 trade unionists continue to be
detained and that prisoners, including trade unionists, report instances of torture and
sexual violence. The military authorities simply indicate that the MICS-TUsF General
Secretary has access to adequate medical care, confirm that Kyaw Naing Oo and Paing Thae
Oo are currently serving their sentence and reiterate that no union member has been
arrested or had cases filed against them for simply exercising labour rights or engaging
in activities for the restoration of democracy.
- 460. Deeply concerned by these disturbing allegations and in the absence
of any concrete or meaningful reply from the military authorities refuting them, the
Committee must recall that the detention of trade unionists for reasons connected with
their activities in defence of the interests of workers constitutes a serious
interference with civil liberties in general and with trade union rights in particular.
It is not possible for a stable industrial relations system to function harmoniously in
the country as long as trade unionists are subject to arrests and detentions [see
Compilation of decisions of the Committee on Freedom of Association, sixth edition,
2018, paras 123 and 127]. Furthermore, the Committee has considered that detained trade
unionists, like all other persons, should enjoy the guarantees enunciated in the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on Civil and
Political Rights according to which all persons deprived of their liberty must be
treated with humanity and with respect for the inherent dignity of the human person [see
Compilation, para. 110]. If allegations of torture or ill-treatment in detention are
raised, concrete and appropriate measures should be taken to apply effective sanctions
and give precise instructions to the relevant officials to ensure that no detainee is
subjected to such treatment. In light of the above and further recalling the ILO
Governing Body’s repeated call on the military authorities to immediately end the
arbitrary arrest, detention and torture of trade unionists in the exercise of their
human rights and to ensure the immediate release of those detained, the Committee urges
for steps to be taken without delay to ensure the immediate release of trade unionists
and workers arrested or detained for action in relation to the restoration of their
trade union rights and democracy in the country, including Thet Hnin Aung, the MICS-TUsF
General Secretary, and Naing Lin Aung, the recently arrested youth activist. The
Committee requests to be informed of concrete steps taken in this regard and to provide
a copy of the judgment against Thet Hnin Aung. The Committee also calls on the military
authorities to take all necessary measures to ensure that, pending release, detained
workers and unionists are treated with dignity and are not subjected to any form of
physical or mental abuse.
- 461. With regard to the use of violence against workers and trade
unionists participating in peaceful protests and independent investigations into
allegations of violence (recommendation (c)), the Committee notes with deep concern the
additional information from the complainant alleging a deteriorating environment for the
exercise of labour rights, in particular, an increased use of lethal weapons against
civilians, including workers and unionists who are labelled as supporters of terrorism,
the PDF or foreign agents. The Committee regrets to observe the total lack of
information from the military authorities in this respect, besides affirming that they
consider some CTUM leaders as associated with groups declared by the military as
terrorist and reiterating that no union member has been subjected to violence for
exercising their labour rights. The Committee understands, from the information provided
by the complainant, as well as publicly available information, that the continued
widespread and extreme violence in the country not only affects the civilian population
in general but also workers and trade unionists in particular, seriously restricting
unions’ ability to engage in legitimate activities. The Committee must therefore recall
that a genuinely free and independent trade union movement cannot develop in a climate
of violence and uncertainty. The exercise of trade union rights is incompatible with
violence or threats of any kind and it is for the authorities to investigate without
delay and, if necessary, penalize any act of this kind. Blanket linkages of trade unions
to an insurgency have a stigmatizing effect and often place union leaders and members in
a situation of extreme insecurity [see Compilation, paras 86, 88 and 93]. In line with
the above, the Committee once again urges the responsible military authorities to
immediately cease the ongoing use of violence against workers and trade unionists
participating in peaceful protests or otherwise engaged in legitimate trade union
activities and to have independent investigations carried out into the allegations of
violence against them with a view to determining responsibilities and punishing the
perpetrators. The Committee requests to be informed of all steps taken in this regard
and the outcome of the investigations.
- 462. Regarding steps to reinstate citizenship to the trade unionists and
workers concerned (recommendation (c)), the Committee notes with concern the
complainant’s allegations that the citizenship or passports of the CTUM leadership
remain void and that, in addition to these measures, the military authorities have been
engaged in continuing attacks and a smearing campaign against the CTUM aimed at
discrediting the organization and interfering in its internal affairs, as well as those
of other independent trade unions. In this regard, the complainant alleges that the
military authorities supported the establishment of a parallel trade union confederation
with the same name as the CTUM in Burmese and that fake congresses were organized at
which workers were asked, under military coercion and surveillance, to elect new CTUM
and IWFM leadership from a pre-determined list of pro-military individuals to replace
the incumbent leadership (relevant documents were submitted to the Committee but were
requested to be kept confidential). The complainant raises concerns that this anti-union
attack aims at taking over independent trade unions and turning them into an agency of
the State and that workers are forced into organizations that are under the control or
influence of the military or businesses that are themselves under the influence of the
military. The Committee observes that while the military authorities do not contest that
a congress was held in February 2025 to elect new CTUM leadership, they refute the
allegation that this creates a parallel organization. Instead, they assert that the new
CTUM leadership was elected on the request of CTUM members who considered that the
organization’s structure had collapsed and lacked leadership. According to the military
authorities, some CTUM leaders, including the President, have not participated in labour
matters since February 2021, have deviated from their intended purpose by failing to
carry out organizational affairs, acted against ILO principles and failed to provide an
account of the organization’s assets, as requested by CTUM members in the country. They
assert that the new leaders were therefore elected through free and fair elections, in
line with the applicable legislation and the organization’s constitution, to fill the
vacant executive and central committee positions and to allow the CTUM to continue to
carry out its duties. Regarding the confiscation of passports or citizenship of trade
unionists, the military authorities reiterate that actions have only been taken against
individuals cooperating with armed organizations engaged in destructive activities and
undermining national stability, unrelated to labour activities.
- 463. The Committee must recall that the current situation, in which
numerous trade unionists, including CTUM leaders, were forced to flee the country or go
into hiding for fear of their lives because of their opposition to the forceful
imposition of a military regime, stems directly from the February 2021 coup d’état
conducted by the military authorities. The Committee therefore considers that this
situation cannot be used by these same authorities to justify the unionists’ perceived
lack of engagement in trade union affairs or as a valid argument for replacement of CTUM
leadership, especially considering that, according to the information available to the
Committee, the CTUM leaders remain active in servicing their members and engaging in
union activities in various territories across the State and to the extent permitted by
the current context. Further, given the worrying allegations of military support and
involvement in the process, the Committee must recall that any interference by the
authorities and the political party in power concerning the presidency of the central
trade union organization in a country is incompatible with the principle that
organizations shall have the right to elect their representatives in full freedom. The
presence during trade union elections of the authorities is liable to infringe freedom
of association and, in particular, to be incompatible with the principle that workers’
and employers’ organizations shall have the right to elect their representatives in full
freedom, and that the public authorities should refrain from any interference which
would restrict this right or impede the lawful exercise thereof [see Compilation, paras
638 and 646]. In light of the above, emphasizing the importance of trade unions
remaining independent not only from employers and their organizations but also from the
authorities, the Committee, like the Commission of Inquiry, urges the military
authorities to immediately cease any action that can be reasonably considered as
interference in the internal affairs of independent trade unions, including support for
the organization of elections or replacement of executive committee members. The
Committee also calls once again on the military authorities to reinstate citizenship and
return passports to the trade unionists and workers concerned, to cease any other action
that is perceived as an anti-union attack or campaign against independent unions and to
indicate the steps taken in this regard.
- 464. Regarding steps to ensure the reinstatement of all remaining civil
servants, healthcare workers and teachers dismissed or suspended for their participation
in the CDM and to restore any benefits that may have been withdrawn (recommendation
(e)), the Committee has previously recalled that for the contribution of trade unions
and employers’ organizations to be properly useful and credible, they must be able to
carry out their activities in a climate of freedom and security. This implies that, in
so far as they may consider that they do not have the basic freedom to fulfil their
mission directly, trade unions and employers’ organizations would be justified in
demanding that these freedoms and the right to exercise them be recognized and that
these demands be considered as coming within the scope of legitimate trade union
activities [see Compilation, para. 75]. Taking note of the reiterated information that,
following their suspensions for unauthorized absence, 7,904 civil servants have since
been reinstated, the Committee calls once again on the responsible authorities to
continue to take steps to ensure the reinstatement of all remaining civil servants,
healthcare workers and teachers dismissed or suspended for their participation in the
CDM and to restore any benefits that may have been withdrawn.
- 465. Concerning the repeal and amendment of sections 124 and 505-A of the
Penal Code and section 38(c) of the Electronic Transaction Act (ETA), the withdrawal of
the surveillance powers that were restored to the wards and villages under the amended
Ward or Village-tract Administration Law, and the withdrawal of the declaration that
made certain trade unions unlawful (recommendation (d)), the Committee notes with regret
the complainant’s allegations that no concrete steps were taken to repeal or amend the
above provisions and observes that the military authorities themselves refer to the use
of sections 124-A and 505-A of the Penal Code against trade unionists (section 124-A was
amended post-military coup to penalize acts of causing hatred, contempt or
dissatisfaction towards the defence services and their personnel while section 505-A was
newly introduced and establishes the crime of causing fear, spreading false news or
agitating a crime against a Government employee). While the military authorities further
assert that amendments have only been made to national laws for security purposes, since
the country is in a state of emergency, the complainant alleges that additional measures
were taken by the military authorities to restrict basic civil liberties and, in
particular, freedom of expression. The Committee notes that since May 2024 the use of
personal data protection and social media applications by individuals has been
prohibited and that the newly adopted Cybersecurity Law No. 1/2025 puts into effect the
ban on unapproved usage and stipulates penalties of imprisonment of up to six months for
the use of VPNs and up to two years for transmission of unwanted or unsolicited data via
a network, including from media or groups labelled as terrorists. Observing that,
according to the complainant, these new measures seriously restrict the already limited
exercise of trade union rights in the country, including communication and provision of
union services, the Committee must recall that freedom of opinion and expression and, in
particular, the right not to be penalized for one’s opinions, is an essential corollary
of freedom of association, and workers, employers and their organizations should enjoy
freedom of opinion and expression in their meetings, publications and in the course of
their trade union activities. The authorities threatening to press criminal charges in
response to legitimate opinions of trade union representatives may have an intimidating
and detrimental effect on the exercise of trade union rights [see Compilation, paras 235
and 237]. In view of the above, the Committee urges the repeal of the newly adopted
Cybersecurity Law No. 1/2025 and of any other measures that unduly restrict the exercise
of freedom of opinion and expression, including excessive penalties. In view of the
total lack of action in this regard, and in the same vein as the Commission of Inquiry
and the ILO Governing Body, the Committee once again firmly urges the repeal and
amendment of sections 124 and 505-A of the Penal Code and section 38(c) of the ETA, the
withdrawal of the surveillance powers that were restored to the wards and villages under
the amended Ward or Village-tract Administration Law, and the withdrawal of the
declaration making certain trade unions unlawful so as to ensure full respect for the
basic civil liberties necessary for the exercise of freedom of association so that
workers’ and employers’ organizations can carry out their activities and functions
without threat of intimidation or harm and in a climate of complete security.
- 466. With regard to ensuring a climate conducive to the full exercise of
freedom of association for all workers and employers and recognizing the critical
importance of civil liberties as a necessary prerequisite for the exercise of trade
union activities (recommendations (f) and (g)), the Committee notes with deep concern
the complainant’s allegations of a deteriorating environment for the exercise of labour
rights since its last examination of the case, with the environment having become
extremely dangerous for trade unionists and labour rights activists who are labelled as
supporters of terrorism, the PDF or foreign agents, the use of torture and sexual abuse
in detention, the continued application of martial law and increased restrictions on
basic civil liberties, which the Committee understands have practically inhibited the
legitimate exercise of trade union rights in the country and have led to a denial of any
possible protection of the civil liberties necessary for workers and employers to be
able to carry out their activities in a climate of complete freedom and security.
Contrary to these concerns, the military authorities express commitment to upholding and
adhering to freedom of association and assert that Myanmar practises freedom of
association, that the Ministry of Labour has not hindered activities of labour
organizations and monitors labour-related demands and that 64 new workers’ organizations
were formed since October 2024. While taking note of these general assertions, the
Committee observes that the military authorities omit to address the persistent concerns
about severe restrictions on basic civil liberties hindering the exercise of trade union
rights and do not elaborate on any concrete measures taken to remedy these restrictions.
In these circumstances, recalling the repeated calls of the ILO Governing Body on the
military authorities to ensure that employer’s and workers’ organizations are able to
exercise their rights in a climate of freedom and security, the Committee must once
again call on Myanmar to give the highest priority to ensuring respect for basic civil
liberties of workers and employers, which are a prerequisite for the exercise of freedom
of association, and to take all the necessary measures to create a climate where freedom
of association can be fully and meaningfully restored in Myanmar. The Committee also
once again urges the military authorities to desist from any and all acts of retaliation
against any individual or organization which provided information to the Commission of
Inquiry or continues to engage in the ILO procedures ensuring follow-up to the
Commission’s recommendations.
- 467. In conclusion, the Committee expresses the deepest regret at the
human and material losses caused by the earthquake that occurred in central Myanmar at
the end of March 2025 and recognizes the disastrous consequences it has had on the
lives, health and well-being of the population. The Committee extends condolences to the
people of Myanmar and expresses its support for and solidarity with the people. The
Committee notes with deep concern the latest information provided by the complainant
alleging continuous, deliberate and indiscriminate aerial bombings of civilian areas in
the aftermath of the earthquake, despite a military-declared ceasefire, as well as
systematic obstruction of rescues, causing imminent threat to the lives and activities
of the remaining independent unionists. In these circumstances, the Committee urges the
military authorities to immediately cease all violence against civilians and trade
unionists exercising their legitimate civil liberties and freedom of association rights.
It also urges rapid and genuine implementation of its recommendations, as well as those
of the Commission of Inquiry, which it considers would constitute a significant
contribution to the efforts to rebuild the country and ensure an environment conducive
to the full exercise of freedom of association.
- 468. Noting with deep regret the continued failure of the military
authorities to implement the recommendations of the Commission of Inquiry and of this
Committee, as well as the continuing situation of extreme violence and repression in the
country, the Committee draws the Governing Body’s attention to the serious and urgent
nature of this case.
The Committee’s recommendations
The Committee’s recommendations- 469. In the light of its foregoing interim conclusions, the Committee
invites the Governing Body to approve the following recommendations:
- (a) The
Committee urges for steps to be taken without delay to ensure the immediate release
of trade unionists and workers arrested or detained for action in relation to the
restoration of their trade union rights and democracy in the country, including Thet
Hnin Aung, the General Secretary of the Myanmar Industry, Crafts and Services Trade
Union Federation (MICS-TUsF), and Naing Lin Aung, the recently arrested youth
activist. The Committee requests to be informed of concrete steps taken in this
regard and to provide a copy of the judgment against Thet Hnin Aung. The Committee
also calls on the military authorities to take all necessary measures to ensure
that, pending release, detained workers and unionists are treated with dignity and
are not subjected to any form of physical or mental abuse.
- (b) The Committee
once again urges the responsible military authorities to immediately cease the
ongoing use of violence against workers and trade unionists participating in
peaceful protests or otherwise engaged in legitimate trade union activities and to
have independent investigations carried out into the allegations of violence against
them with a view to determining responsibilities and punishing the perpetrators. The
Committee requests to be informed of all steps taken in this regard and the outcome
of the investigations.
- (c) The Committee urges the military authorities to
immediately cease any action that can be reasonably considered as interference in
the internal affairs of independent trade unions, including support for the
organization of elections or replacement of executive committee members. The
Committee also calls once again on the military authorities to reinstate citizenship
and return passports to the trade unionists and workers concerned, to cease any
other action that is perceived as an anti-union attack or campaign against
independent unions and to indicate the steps taken in this regard.
- (d) The
Committee calls once again on the responsible authorities to continue to take steps
to ensure the reinstatement of all remaining civil servants, healthcare workers and
teachers dismissed or suspended for their participation in the civil disobedience
movement (CDM) and to restore any benefits that may have been withdrawn.
- (e)
The Committee urges the repeal of the newly adopted Cybersecurity Law No. 1/2025 and
of any other measures that unduly restrict the exercise of freedom of opinion and
expression, including excessive penalties. The Committee once again firmly urges the
repeal and amendment of sections 124 and 505-A of the Penal Code and section 38(c)
of the Electronic Transaction Act (ETA), the withdrawal of the surveillance powers
that were restored to the wards and villages under the amended Ward or Village-tract
Administration Law, and the withdrawal of the declaration making certain trade
unions unlawful so as to ensure full respect for the basic civil liberties necessary
for the exercise of freedom of association so that workers’ and employers’
organizations can carry out their activities and functions without threat of
intimidation or harm and in a climate of complete security.
- (f) The
Committee must once again call on Myanmar to give the highest priority to ensuring
respect for basic civil liberties of workers and employers, which are a prerequisite
for the exercise of freedom of association, and to take all the necessary measures
to create a climate where freedom of association can be fully and meaningfully
restored in Myanmar. The Committee also once again urges the military authorities to
desist from any and all acts of retaliation against any individual or organization
which provided information to the Commission of Inquiry or continues to engage in
the ILO procedures ensuring follow-up to the Commission’s
recommendations.
- (g) Expressing its deep regret and condolences for the
human and material losses caused by the earthquake that occurred in central Myanmar
at the end of March 2025, the Committee urges rapid and genuine implementation of
these recommendations, as well as those of the Commission of Inquiry, as a
significant contribution to the efforts to rebuild the country and ensure an
environment conducive to the full exercise of freedom of association. Deeply
concerned by the allegations of continuous and deliberate attacks against civilian
areas in the aftermath of the earthquake, the Committee urges the military
authorities to immediately cease all violence against civilians and trade unionists
exercising their legitimate civil liberties and freedom of association
rights.
- (h) Noting with deep regret the continued failure of the military
authorities to implement the recommendations of the Commission of Inquiry and of
this Committee, as well as the continuing situation of extreme violence and
repression in the country, the Committee draws the Governing Body’s attention to the
serious and urgent nature of this case.